Sunday, October 17, 2010


There is a site I belong to that gives its members the freedom to review a book by one word:




Or, almost as bad, to review a book by simply using stars:

The guidelines are: 1 star: I hated it
                             2 stars: it was okay
                             3 stars: I liked it
                             4 stars: I really loved it
                             5 stars: It was amazing.

What do you think about this kind of book reviewing?


At 18 October, 2010 , Blogger Karen Elizabeth Brown said...

Seems to me that a writer who is reviewing a piece would have more to say about ANYTHING than just one word sentences. Besides, it doesn't do the author any good if he/she can't learn and grow from the reviews.
Stars are good when you are selling things and I realize there are time and limited space issues. But there needs to be good feedback, if that's the purpose of the exercise, or it would be wasted time and energy on everyone's part.

At 18 October, 2010 , Blogger Retta said...

I TOTALLY agree with Karen, only she said it better!

Whenever anyone says to me "I like that" about something I have created, I am almost always tempted to ask "why?".


At 18 October, 2010 , Blogger Unknown said...

If only evaluation was this simple. If I wrote this on a student's paper, I'm certain they would never improve their writing, and may actually question whether or not I've read their paper since I can't express why it's bad or good. These are such ambiguous statements. A writer needs to understand why something works or doesn't work. A one liner may work for describing your kitten as cute, but doesn't work when evaluating writing.

Stars are great as a heading of some sort, but should never stand alone to speak for themselves. For instance, I've watched so many amazing movies whose rating was rather low on the IMDb or similar rating site. Had I let the rating system prevent me from enjoying these movies, I'd be missing out on some great art. Similarly, I've seen movies that are horrid but have great scores. Ratings are subjective, and because of this, arguing why you use the descriptors that you do helps to put that subjectivity into perspective so the audience can better grasp what's at stake.

Granted, people can be lazy, and a star rating is a great way to avoid wasting time. Then again, those who think reading is ever a waste of time probably wouldn't even read an extended review, anyway.

At 12 August, 2014 , Blogger oakleyses said...

hogan, nfl jerseys, abercrombie and fitch, lululemon, chi flat iron, nike free, marc jacobs, rolex watches, soccer shoes, timberland, montre pas cher, beats by dre, birkin bag, celine handbags, karen millen, oakley pas cher, mont blanc, ralph lauren, herve leger, ghd, reebok outlet, vans, burberry, bottega, hermes, air max, nike air max, louis vuitton, juicy couture outlet, insanity, new balance shoes, ray ban pas cher, converse shoes, mcm handbags, mulberry, hollister, jimmy choo, ugg boots, louis vuitton, valentino, supra shoes, ferragamo shoes, asics gel, soccer jerseys, wedding dresses, p90x3, michael kors, north face outlet, lancel, yoga pants

At 10 June, 2015 , Blogger Unknown said...

tommy hilfiger outlet
vans shoes
mulberry outlet
air max 2014
manchester united jersey
chicago bears jerseys
miami heat jersey
chelsea jersey
ugg uk
true religion jeans
rolex watches uk
the north face outlet store
christian louboutin uk
new york giants jerseys
coach outlet canada
nike roshe
boston celtics jersey
hermes outlet
new york knicks jersey
new england patriots jerseys
ysl outlet
baltimore ravens jerseys
evening dresses
ralph lauren uk
chicago blackhawks jersey
san antonio spurs jerseys
oklahoma city thunder jerseys
chanel outlet
oakland raiders jerseys
michael kors uk
denver broncos jerseys
tory burch outlet
air max 2015
canada goose outlet
nike free uk
swarovski uk
koby bryant shoes
mbt shoes
coach outlet
cheap wedding dresses
minnesota vikings jerseys

At 04 December, 2015 , Blogger mmjiaxin said...

ferragamo shoes
michael kors outlet
rolex watches outlet
tory burch outlet online
michael kors handbags
coach outlet store
mac cosmetics
michael kors outlet online
wellensteyn outlet
michael kors outlet
canada goose outelt
air max 2014
ray ban,rayban,occhiali ray ban,ray-ban,ray ban occhiali,ray ban sunglasses
woolrich outlet store
fred perry polo shirts
michael kors outlet
tiffany outlet
canada goose jackets
oakley outlet store
mizuno running shoes

At 26 August, 2016 , Blogger said...

20160827 junda.
jordan 11
coach outlet clearance
longchamp handbags
tory burch outlet
nike blazer pas cher
coach outlet online
coach outlet
ugg boots
coach outlet store
timberland shoes
swarovski jewelry
nike air huarache
longchamp outlet
swarovski crystal
mulberry handbags
longchamp outlet
prada outlet
ugg outlet
coach outlet online
michael kors outlet clearance
hollister uk
ugg outlet
rolex watches,rolex replica watches,replica rolex watches,replica watches
adidas wings shoes
uggs outlet
true religion jeans outlet
ferragamo shoes
ugg boots sale
adidas nmd
nike trainers uk
pandora outlet
gucci outlet online
moncler jackets
ralph lauren uk
cheap ugg boots
ugg outlet
mulberry outlet
nike air force 1
nike air max 2015

At 19 December, 2017 , Blogger Unknown said...

michael kors outlet
nike outlet store
tory burch outlet
coach outlet
adidas nmd
ralph lauren outlet
pandora charms
canada goose outlet
harden vol 1

At 29 September, 2021 , Blogger Source Essay said...

Do you need to submit your dissertations by the end of this semister? A lot of students face panic attacks when their deadlines are knocking at the door. This is because they understand the repercussions of not submitting dissertations on time. Research papers come with different guidelines. But there are two criterions that are same for every assignment.
assignment proofreading help
dissertation vs thesis writing service
Online Assignment Help
Online Assignment Help Croydon
Admission Essay Help
instant assignment help
Dissertation Writing Service


Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home