Monday, October 18, 2010

The Serving of your Story Part 2: Authority

At the end of September -  was it only a bit more than  two weeks ago? - I posted this to my blog:

When you write, you don't write primarily from the mind, you write out of the love you feel for the people in your story, which means everything you write is meant to serve these people and does not exist to fulfil some intellectual goal of your own, such as getting published.

There were quite a few comments, and I thought a couple of them needed more space than the ridiculously few characters allowed in a comment.  Here's the first one.




At 04 October, 2010 , Blogger Quenby said...






In the past, when I was writing creatively and not academically, I would always base my characters on my family members. I would take small problems or troubling characteristics/situations they had and turn them into a character-defining dimension.


Because I used real people to base my fiction on, I felt so very close to my creations because, while they are severely flawed or fragmented(both my characters and the members of my immediate and extended family)I love them all dearly. I may sometimes be conflicted in my feelings, but there is always love. Investing so much emotion into characters can be exhausting because it forces you to face the aspects of the real people your characters are based on, and it's not always pretty. Through this type of writing, I've found myself able to forgive my characters, who may emphasize a certain flaw more than the real person, and in this way, it can be so very cathartic when you look at the real life inspiration and see their smaller flaw in comparison.

I don't know if this makes much sense, but what I'm trying to articulate is that creative writing can be so very personal, so essential, and so entirely necessary that when you choose to put your work out there for publication only to have it shot down, it can be devastating. I haven't attempted publishing any of my creative writing, but I can surmise that if anyone were to reject my characters or their stories, it would seem like a slight against those dear to me. I want people to be able to forgive my characters the way I have.


---------------------
Your comments about loving the characters in your stories are different from what I meant when I talked about loving and serving the characters and the story. I'm really glad you brought these points up, however, because you write so cleanly and without confusion that I understand what you are saying and I'm sure other people will understand it too.  By asking it so clearly, I can, I hope, answer you in such a way that other people will gain their own answers too.   I hope, too, that I will be able to provide you (and the rest of the people reading this) with some things to think about, and at least a hint at some of the answers you need.

WHY NOT USE PEOPLE YOU KNOW IN YOUR STORIES?  WHY NOT JUST GIVE THEM NEW NAMES AND USE THEM?  EVERYONE HAS TROUBLE WITH THEIR FAMILIES.  WHY NOT WRITE FROM THE FIRST PERSON AND JUST CHANGE THE NAME OTHER PEOPLE CALL YOU BY IN THE STORY?  WHY NOT WRITE A STORY ABOUT THE FAMILY AND THE TROUBLE YOU'VE HAD WITH THEM -- AND KILL FOUR BIRDS WITH ONE STONE?   (four birds: tell you later.)  These are questions that have come up so many, many times in writing workshops that you needn't feel you've asked something that other people instinctively know.  Virtually no writer I know has ever expressed to me the answers to the above questions, though all the writers I know and respect do NOT use people they know as characters, and do NOT use their own problems, and do NOT write as if they are the main character. 

One problem is that you know your own family.  You learn even more about your own family as you write about them.  It makes you uncomfortable, exhausted even. You add more of the character flaws to the people you love because that is what the story is about, and you get even more exhausted.  Eventually, through writing creatively about them, you come to some kind of resolution that allows you, Quenby, to understand and forgive your own flesh and blood. 

But what has this to do with other peoples' flesh and blood?  This is what has you in a turmoil, Quenby.  Unless you have the freedom to create, to change characters in a major way from the way you believe 100% that they are in your own real life, it is very difficult to make those characters connect to other peoples' flesh and blood.  I know you won't quite believe that.  You'll say, "But I have a friend whose parents did that to her."  And I'll say truthfully, "That's sad.  Was it exactly that, what they did to your friend?  And do you know why they did it?  Was it for the very same reason as your parents did what they did to you?" 

Now in saying this, I'm not really writing about your parents, Quenby.  I don't even know your parents.  I don't know your friend, or your friend's parents.  I don't know what the problem is that your "parents" did to "you" and that you are "writing out".  My connections to everything here are only as true as you can make them be for me.  

"Well I'll just write more about them, and then you'll know," you might say.

"Maybe I don't really believe that you are remembering with 100% truth everything you've already written,"  one of your readers might say, who will perhaps have just seen or will have seen early on through the "fictional" first person narrator to know it's really you, the author.  You would have entered your own story somehow, and the reader would have seen it. 

How?  I believe it has to do with AUTHORITY.

An author has authority because s/he knows 100% of what happened in the story and why.  S/he has notes.  S/he has what s/he has already written.  S/he has friends to tell him or her, after reading something, "Hey man, why didn't your main character just go live with his best friend?"  To an author, that would be an option, one that would be carefully considered, and even (okay, I'm not as crazy as this sounds :}) would kind of been talked over with the character, to see if it's something the character would choose to do under these circumstances.  But a writer who is writing a story based on coloured fact, would simply say, "He didn't, that's all."

Authority. 

And now we are into the first place where fact is different from fiction.  Your life seen through your eyes, is very different than your life seen through your family's eyes.  Truth is somewhere in there.  Some things are true, some are only true in your eyes, some are never true.  I know this.  I have a daughter.  She remembers some things one way.  I remember those episodes quite differently.  The truth is in there somewhere, but it's not for sure 100% accurate in my mind and it's not for sure 100% accurate in my daughter's mind.  Neither of us are liars.  Nor are you, Quenby.  All this problem with truth happens because no one really knows the whole truth of a real life story the way a writer of fiction knows the whole truth of a fictional story. 

Memory colours events.  We just had a guest for the weekend.  This is a fact.  A story came up about a thing that happened 25 years ago.  The two guys were going to do a musical gig on radio.  One of them remembers (or so I was re-told this morning) that he had to keep using the bathroom.  The other of them remembers that neither of them ever even left the car because a panic attack was going on.  Today, having heard the story, last night, I remembered our guest saying he'd gotten locked in the bathroom.  I also remember the panic attack story.  There's truth in what I remember.  But what part of my memory is the exact truth?  Can I even be 100% sure that the one that remembers the panic attack in the parked car remembers it 100% accurately?

You are right to say you can't easily "expose" your stories to a critic's gaze.  You didn't say this, but I know that part of the reason you are uncomfortable and exhausted at the thought is that you are stifled by the reality that your parents/siblings/cousins/etc. will read your story no matter how you try to hide its publication from them, and know what you think of them, or thought of them, before you wrote your way to understanding and forgiving them.  You know very well they don't see themselves the way you do. That they never thought of themselves the way you did.  Worse, in making them a bit "worse" or "different" for the sake of the conflict you're writing this story around, they will see the exaggeration and nothing else you could ever say will bring them back to you with love.  They don't care if you forgive them in the end of the story, because they don't realize what on earth made you think they needed forgiveness in the first place.   Therefore, what is true for you isn't true for them.

Kill four birds with one stone: your family's sense of itself, yourself in relationship to them in your mind once you've "written it out" and seen how much less bad they are than you had thought, yourself in relationship to them once they read the story, and -- the story itself.  You'll kill it for sure, because you won't have served all the characters in it with the kind of love that lets them be what they are. 

 A fiction writer would let them be what they are, even mean.  By letting them be that way, the fiction writer (a very good one, anyway) would come to understand why they are that way.  Remember Margaret Laurence's novel The Stone Angel?  Remember that dreadful female main character?  Did you love her at the end?  I did.  I cried for her.  But a writer can't make that happen for a reader unless s/he has the freedom to allow the characters to slowly explain, through the things they do,  100% of why they are the way they are.  In the end, then, the author will know 100% about everyone and everything in the story.  It won't be a question of what's right and what's wrong, or who remembers what.  In writing about your family, Quenby, you would always be constrained by the fact that they can't be evil, they can't even do real evil,  because you love them. 

Write with authority.  Write fiction.

Make it up, and make it seem real.

Keep on writing your excellent slice-of-life from your point-of-view diaristic but resolved stories, if you want to.  And then hide them until everyone who could ever be hurt by them is dead.  

But don't limit yourself like this, Quenby.  Hang loose, free yourself from reality, and then sit down at the computer and INVENT. 

18 Comments:

At 18 October, 2010 , Blogger M Pax said...

You are speaking of characterization? Writing from the character instead of our own heads. Like I might think the sun suffuses like warm lemon kisses, but my main character would never think that. She'd think something more like - the sunlight ruined my vision like a badly programmed computer. Or something more along those lines.

 
At 18 October, 2010 , Blogger Quenby said...

I really appreciate that you took the time to address my comment. As you can see, my mind's not entirely wired to write effective fiction, as I tend to use reality to work through my problems. I certainly have never expressed anything I've written in my fiction to any of the family members my characters are based on. I know they would be offended and wouldn't be able to divorce the concept of fiction from how they think I truly perceive them. People often internalize the bad before they can even be aware of the good. Granted, there was a time when a story got into the wrong hands.

I once wrote a short story about a member of my family where I framed him as an alcoholic and negligent father. I let my mother read it after telling her who it was based on; she thought it was so great she sent it to that family member to read! I specifically told her to not let anyone else see it, but she seemed to have forgotten that, as she saw it only as a great piece of fiction-- that's easy to think when it's not about you. I can assure you, the family member certainly didn't see things the way I did, as you so astutely noted, Welwyn. After that incident, I haven't written any more fiction, though I still dabble in poetry and personal essay writing. Your words have a resounding truth about them. Great advice, truly.

This incident might very well be why I turned to academia to write, so I could address the reality of society, culture, individual and shared prejudices-- to understand the causes of things, the victims, and the affect of tragedy and joy for certain demographics, genders, races, etc. I don't regret my foray into fiction-writing because it gave me a means of therapy without having to pay someone else a ridiculous sum. It also led me to my passion of understanding people through writing. And though my writing has taken a new form, I'm still dealing with fictional texts, but I'm delving into the truth behind them, and that, to me, is very rewarding.

 
At 18 October, 2010 , Blogger Quenby said...

Just to clarify, I mean to say that fiction does very important cultural work, and my strengths lie with uncovering the reality behind that fiction, and not writing it.

 
At 19 October, 2010 , Blogger Welwyn-on-books said...

Good thinking Quenby. You may not yet know where your greatest strengths are in writing. Never ever show family stuff to family, whether family will love it or not. Family has inner stuff that compells them to do things that you can never understand. As I said, at far too great length.

 
At 19 October, 2010 , Blogger Welwyn-on-books said...

MPax, you're onto it, I think. But don't abandon what you do to understand (100%) your character. There is no time line to that, you see. As long as you know it by the ending of all the polishing, you're laughing!

 
At 17 December, 2014 , Blogger co wendy said...

Cheap LV Handbags, ugg boots, cheap jordans , Christian Louboutin Daffodile, discount christian louboutin, Discount Louis Vuitton, christian louboutin shoes, discount nike jordans, wholesale jordan shoes, ugg soldes, Discount LV Handbags, cheap christian louboutin, Bags Louis Vuitton, ugg, cheap nike jordan shoes, christian louboutin, uggs on sale, Cheap Louis Vuitton Handbags, ugg pas cher, Christian Louboutin Bois Dore, christian louboutin remise 50%, uggs outlet, ugg australia

 
At 08 January, 2015 , Blogger TRXAustralia Best said...

A strap dangles within the ceiling, a door play or ought in relation to whatever else. which is largely used for almost everything feature out of muscle and also aerobic instructions in order to stretches. though special coaches are actually while using the trx workouts for assorted decades.
Straps previously referred to also period of time adjustments so concerning retain a person secure and appear as well as decrease from the precise similar time frame. Most importantly down, the full offer trx strpas sale about solely various pounds.
The following TRX Australia is adjustable at the same time, providing this trouble-free to make use of for virtually every everyone. just about all from the sessions which you'll conduct on this are generally closed string.
Straps previously defined in addition phase alterations and so relating to maintain a person safe and seem possibly at cut down inside the highly accurate exact same time period. To top Cheap TRX UK all away, the full package deal has a weight of simply a number of lbs. don't be turned off simply by its set free seems to be.

 
At 27 March, 2015 , Blogger mao yun said...

4
chanel handbags
ray ban sunglasses
karen millen dresses
tod's sale
nike air max uk
tory burch outlet
ray-ban sunglasses
toms
abercrombie outlet
louis vuitton outlet stores
iphone 6 case
fitflop
abercrombie and fitch
new balance 574
babyliss pro
hollister clothing
puma sneakers
chanel bags
cheap oakley sunglasses
coach outlet
hollister
fred perry polo shirts
fred perry sale
beats by dre
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
hollister clothing
longchamp outlet
timberland shoes
cheap nfl jerseys
coach outlet online
chanel handbags,chanel bags,chanel outlet,chanel 2.55
true religion
polo ralph lauren outlet
oakley sunglasses wholesale
oakley sunglasses wholesale
links of london
ray ban sunglasses uk
toms shoes
coach outlet
salomon shoes
20150328maoqiuyun

 
At 08 September, 2015 , Blogger John said...

gucci
prada
rolex watches outlet
coach factory outlet
louis vuitton outlet
gucci shoes
caoch outlet
kobe bryant shoes 2015
www.louisvuitton.com
michael kors outlet online
coach handags
tory burch flats
michael kors outlet
ray ban sunglasses
coach factory outlet online
replica watches
celine outlet
ugg boots
nike air max
copy watches
louis vuitton outlet
michael kors handbags
instyler max
hollister,hollister co,hollister jeans,hollister.com,hollister ca,hollister clothing
tory burch outlet
michael kors
prada outlet
marc jacobs handbags
adidas uk
michael kors outlet
201598yuanyuan

 
At 08 September, 2015 , Blogger chenlili said...

chenlili20150908
ray-ban wayfarer
michael kors
louis vuitton handbags
ralph lauren outlet
michael kors outlet online
concords 11
michael kors handbags
tod's outlet
gucci handbags
ugg boots
louis vuitton handbags
mont blanc
red timberland boots
prada sunglasses
nike huarache
kate spade sale
michael kors handbags
louis vuitton online shop
red timberland boots
michael kors outlet online sale
ralph lauren outlet
coach outlet online
abercrombie & fitch
nike trainers sale
coach factorty outlet
louis vuitton outlet
fitflops sale
timberland uk
ed hardy outlet
michael kors outlet

 
At 08 September, 2015 , Blogger chenlili said...

nike trainers
jordan retro 11
timberlands
true religion outlet
instyler
prada outlet
gucci bags
ralph lauren polo shirts
adidas superstars
polo ralph lauren
air jordan retro
air max 90
birkin bags
jordan 3 infrared
louis vuitton
louis vuitton handbags
michael kors outlet online
cheap oakley sunglasses
burberry handbags
new jordans
jordan 11 snakeskin
christian louboutin shoes
hollister,hollister co,hollister jeans,hollister.com,hollister ca,hollister clothing
replica rolex watches
ray ban outlet
knockoff watches
ugg boots sale
prada handbags
coach outlet online
michael kors

 
At 06 October, 2015 , Blogger 陈晓 said...

crx123
oraz ugg boots timberland outlet nike store adidas tre?ci nike nike factory store michael kors outlet online sale tommy hilfiger online powszechnie straightener cheap nfl jerseys oakley sunglasses cheap hollister uznanych hollisterco toms outlet chi flat iron nike air max 2014 za hermes birkin louis vuitton outlet online moncler women jackets coach outlet store naganne ray ban outlet beats audio coach bags gucci uk moralnie, burberry outlet online knockoff handbags mac cosmetics swarovski spo?ecznie louis vuitton outlet online ralph lauren uk new balance canada burberry niew?a?ciwe nike roshe chanel handbags rolex replica tiffany i hollister online prada outlet cheap barbour jackets supra shoes naruszaj?cych levis jeans mcm bags vans hermes belt zasady true religion jeans outlet new balance ugg boots hilfiger outlet

 
At 18 November, 2015 , Blogger Wenhao Guo said...

coach outlet online
air force one shoes
longchamp outlet online
nike free
kobe 9 elite
tory burch shoes
asics
seattle seahawks
mizuno shoes
true religion outlet,true religion jeans,true religion kids,true religion jeans sale,true religion jeans for men,true religion jacket,true religion sale
ray ban
oakley sunglasses
ugg outlet
arizona cardinals
ugg boots
beats by dr dre
coach outlet
hermes belt for men
mlb jerseys wholesale
nike air max 2014
tiffany jewelry
ralph lauren sale
wellensteyn coats
michael kors wallets for women
the north face
pandora outlet
michael kors handbags
moncler jackets
tory burch sandals
lululemon outlet
ray-ban sunglasses
coach outlet store
ddddd1119

 
At 25 November, 2015 , Blogger chenlina said...

chenlina20151125
cheap ugg boots
supra shoes
replica watches
ugg sale
ugg sale
ray ban outlet store
cheap uggs
michael kors handbags
uggs for men
coach factory outlet
ed hardy clothing
coach outlet online
running shoes
ray ban sunglasses outlet
gucci shoes
coach outlet store online
kobe 9
ugg boots
canada goose jackets
michael kors outlet online
michael kors bag
lebron shoes
oakley sunglasses cheap
tory burch sale
soccer shoes
canada goose outlet online
louis vuitton purses
michaek kors outlet
the north face
louis vuitton outlet
hollister uk
louis vuitton handbags
jordan retro
michael kors outlet
true religion jeans outlet
jordan retro
ugg boots
polo ralph lauren
ralph lauren uk
jordan 11s
as

 
At 04 December, 2015 , Blogger mmjiaxin said...

herve leger dresses
louis vuitton handbags outlet
coach outlet store
ralph lauren outlet
ray-ban sunglasses
kobe bryants shoes
tiffany and co
karen millen uk
coach outlet online
phone cases
rolex uk
nike free 5
swarovski crystal
louis vuitton handbags outlet
ray ban sunglasses
cheap oakley sunglasses
michael kors canada
nba jerseys
mlb jerseys
michael kors handbags
mm1204

 
At 06 December, 2015 , Blogger Pnane Weg said...

mbt shoes for women
discount nike
nike clearance
red jordans
ugg boots on sale
abercrombie and fitch outlet store
columbia sportswear
jordan retro 3
canada goose coats on sale
jordans for sale
coach purse
coach wallets outlet
Michael Kors Outlet
burberry scarf
nike outlet
nike high heels outlet online
christian louboutin
michael kors sale
new jordan
hermes scarf
supras shoes
celine bags
louboutin shoes
nike outlet store
converse shoes sale
michael kors outlet online
North Face Outlet
coach outlet store online clearances
dior outlet online
retro 11
Kate Spade Shoes
fitflop
canada goose cheap
celine outlet
all jordan shoes
columbia sportswear outlet
mont blanc pen
cheap canada goose
prada outlet
uggs outlet
12.4qwe

 
At 09 December, 2015 , Blogger 方松腾 said...

michael kors handbags,michael kors outlet,michael kors,kors outlet,michael kors outlet online,michael kors outlet online sale,michael kors handbags clearance,michael kors purses,michaelkors.com,michael kors bags,michael kors shoes,michaelkors,cheap michael kors
mlb jerseys wholesale
cheap mlb jerseys
cheap nfl jerseys
nfl jerseys wholesale
nike shoes
cheap oakley sunglasses
snapback hats
soccer jerseys,cheap soccer jerseys,cheap soccer jerseys for sale,soccer jersey,usa soccer jersey,football jerseys
cheap uggs
cheap ugg boots
ugg boots
uggs outlet
wedding dresses
chicago blackhawks

 
At 15 May, 2016 , Blogger mmjiaxin said...

authentic jordans
kobe shoes
ralph lauren online
http://www.jordansforcheap.us.com
cheap air jordan
huaraches shoes
cheap oakley sunglasses
chrome hearts
kobe shoes,kobe zoom,nike zoom kobe
christian louboutin outlet
http://www.cheap--jordans.us.com
nike dunks
http://www.raybanglasses.in.net
http://www.michaelkorshandbagsclearance.com.co
michael kors handbags
oakley outlet online
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet online
ray ban sunglasses,ray ban outlet,ray ban sale,cheap ray bans,cheap ray ban sunglasses,ray ban sunglasses outlet,ray ban,rayban,ray bans,ray-ban,raybans,ray ban wayfarer,ray-ban sunglasses,raybans.com,rayban sunglasses,cheap ray ban
michael kors handbags
gg

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home